Accueil » Music and AI: Suno Found Liable, Major Labels Tighten the Charts

Music and AI: Suno Found Liable, Major Labels Tighten the Charts

par Nathan Reed
0 commentaires
Music studio mixing console with sound waves, a symbol of justice and AI in music

In just a few days, the recording industry dealt a double blow to AI-generated music: a German court found the platform Suno liable for copyright infringement, while the world's biggest record labels are calling for unregulated AI tracks to be excluded from music charts. Here's a look at two decisions that could reshape the rules of the game for artists and listeners alike.

Suno Found Liable by German Court

On July 31, 2026, the Munich Regional Court ruled that the AI music platform Suno had infringed copyright by using, without authorization, works represented by the German collecting society GEMA. Evidence presented showed that the system had memorized and reproduced six protected songs, including the well-known tracks Forever Young and Daddy Cool, from a model trained on more than two million tracks scraped from the internet. The court found two distinct violations: storing the songs within the model's weights, in breach of reproduction rights, and making those outputs available to users, in breach of public communication rights. Suno must now disclose its revenue from this use and will pay damages, the amount of which has yet to be determined. The company has said it disagrees with the ruling and is weighing a possible appeal.

Major Labels Want Charts Free of Unregulated AI

Two days before the ruling, a coalition of about ten of the world's biggest record labels — including the “Big Three” Sony Music, Universal Music Group, and Warner Music Group — published a joint proposal aimed at chart organizations such as Billboard and streaming platforms. The goal: to establish common eligibility rules for tracks that use artificial intelligence. Four conditions are proposed for a track to remain eligible for charts: the AI platform used must be authorized by rights holders, the track must respect copyright and artists' personality rights, the use of AI must be clearly disclosed, and the creation must remain primarily the work of a human, with no manipulation of streams or chart rankings.

Not a Total Ban on AI

Contrary to a hasty reading, this proposal does not ban artificial intelligence from music: a track that uses AI merely as a tool, but that is primarily created by a human artist, can remain eligible. The real target is tracks generated entirely by AI from unlicensed catalogs, sometimes referred to by industry professionals as “AI slop.” The proposal, however, is not yet binding: each platform and each chart remains free to adopt it or not.

What This Means for Listeners and Artists

  • The German ruling sets a European precedent: training an AI on protected catalogs without a license now carries the real risk of lawsuits.
  • Independent artists gain significant leverage against generative AI platforms that had been using their work without compensation.
  • Charts could eventually display clearer labeling of whether a track's origin is human or artificial.
  • Streaming platforms and music apps will need to adapt their detection tools to enforce these future rules.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Suno have to stop operating in Europe?

No, the Munich court's ruling condemns a specific practice — unauthorized training on protected works — without requiring the service to shut down. Suno can appeal the decision.

Are all songs created with AI assistance excluded from the charts?

No. Only tracks generated entirely by AI from unlicensed catalogs, or whose use of AI is not disclosed, would be affected by the new rules proposed by the record labels.

Is this record label proposal already in effect?

Not yet. It is a joint proposal addressed to chart organizations and streaming platforms, which remain free to adopt it on their own timeline.

Sources

This article was written with the help of artificial intelligence. Editorial policy

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi

Editorial policy and use of artificial intelligence