Accueil » Ultra-Processed Foods: Toward Mandatory Labeling in Supermarkets?

Ultra-Processed Foods: Toward Mandatory Labeling in Supermarkets?

par Nathan Reed
0 commentaires
Illustration of processed food products on a supermarket shelf

More than six out of ten packaged products sold in French supermarkets today are ultra-processed foods, according to consumer advocacy groups. Faced with this finding, a bill introduced in the National Assembly and a mobilization by several NGOs are putting back on the table a question that has gone unanswered for years: should mandatory labeling be imposed to clearly flag these products on packaging?

A Marker That Nutri-Score Misses

Nutri-Score ranks products according to their nutritional quality—sugar, salt, fat—but says nothing about their degree of industrial processing. Yet the advocacy groups Foodwatch, Yuka, and France Assos Santé (a French federation of health and patient advocacy associations) point out that about 80% of products rated C, D, or E on the Nutri-Score scale are also ultra-processed, meaning they are made with thickeners, texturizing agents, emulsifiers, or preservatives rarely found in a home kitchen. A Foodwatch investigation identified products that mask their true nature behind claims like “no preservatives” or “no added sugar,” even though they contain several additives characteristic of ultra-processing.

A Bill in Committee

About twenty lawmakers have introduced a bill currently under review by the Social Affairs Committee of the National Assembly. It calls for three measures: labeling ultra-processed foods on packaging, banning them from using flattering nutritional or health claims, and gradually excluding them from institutional catering—school cafeterias, hospitals, nursing homes. For their part, the advocacy groups are demanding a visible signal on the front of the package, in the form of a banner placed alongside the Nutri-Score, rather than a note buried in the ingredient list.

  • More than 60% of packaged products in supermarkets are believed to be ultra-processed.
  • They are estimated to account for 30 to 35% of calories consumed in France.
  • About a hundred studies, including several published in The Lancet, link their regular consumption to an increased risk of chronic disease.
  • The bill under review calls for their gradual removal from institutional catering.

What This Would Change for Consumers

For now, nothing requires a manufacturer to disclose a product's degree of processing: only the ingredient list, often long and hard to read, offers any clue. Dedicated labeling would provide an immediate reference point, comparable to what the Nutri-Score has represented for nutritional quality. This issue also ties into a broader debate about the reliability of information on store shelves: recent overhauls of the Nutri-Score calculation had already shifted the ranking of many everyday products, while inspections revealed the presence of metals such as cadmium in certain packages of pasta. In a context where cost-price selling in supermarkets is already pushing retailers to overhaul their product ranges, clear labeling on industrial processing could weigh on purchasing decisions as much as on manufacturers' recipes.

This story falls under the site's Food section, at the crossroads of the issues covered in Economy.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an ultra-processed food?

It is a product made from industrial ingredients and additives (thickeners, emulsifiers, flavorings, preservatives) rarely used in home cooking, according to the Nova scientific classification used by researchers.

Does the Nutri-Score already flag this type of product?

Not directly: the Nutri-Score assesses overall nutritional quality (sugar, salt, fat), not the degree of industrial processing, which explains why some well-rated products remain ultra-processed.

Where does the bill stand in the National Assembly?

The bill is currently under review by the Social Affairs Committee; it calls for specific labeling, restrictions on health claims, and the gradual phase-out of these products from institutional catering.

Sources

This article was written with the help of artificial intelligence. Editorial policy

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi

Editorial policy and use of artificial intelligence